« Cult of the amateur | Main | MTV Unplugged reborn, will stream video »


Top 5 stoopid YouTube questions for politicians

Like I've said before, YouTube is bad for politics. The granular level of participation induces a level of pandering which, at best, leads to a John McCain "bomb Iran" moment (useless political theater) and at worst results in Hillary Clinton's woefully-insipid campaign song videos and Barak Obama ringtones. The new YouTube politics is entertainment. Pandering entertainment that contributes nothing -- absolutely nothing -- to civic discourse. And if you think it's bad now, wait until next Spring when Mark Burnett launches his political reality show, Independent, on MySpace.

So I'm really enjoying this top 5 post by 10ZenMonkeys: "While it’s morbidly amusing to imagine candidates groveling for LonelyGirl15’s endorsement, YouTube is slyly attempting to appear democratic without actually accomplishing anything. But maybe that’s YouTube’s cynical comment on democracy itself. Maybe they’re imagining the event’s slogan as: “It’s participatory! It’s YouTube! And it’s stupid! Just like voting…""

p.s. Check this article at the Economist, which gives a nice overview of the situation but provides absolutely no critical analysis.

Post a comment

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451d69069e200e008cc51e98834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Top 5 stoopid YouTube questions for politicians:

» Quick Hits June 26, 2007 from e.politics: online advocacy tools & tactics
Why MySpace is for freaks and Facebook is for preps. I KNEW I felt out of place on FacebookSalons Machinist blog looks at a new analysis of the two sites different demographics. Facebook Spam on the Rise the Changing Face ... [Read More]

© 2007 The Nielsen Company. All rights reserved. Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy.